MoosedHistory
Menu
Inventors & Inventions

Inventors & Inventions

Contested Firsts — No "First" Claim Survives as a Patent Claim for This Ground

The exact page text, read by your browser's voice.

Each "first" thread for this ground separated strand by strand from the patent record worked in this section

Lead:Strand two, the steel works' "world's most advanced" language at its 1990 opening: a trade-press superlative about a plant whose process was patterned on a Japanese pilot plant — a claim about installation, not invention, and no patent for this ground stands behind it. Strand three, the residence patents themselves: Rose's sign-printer, Unger's ampoule machine, Evancich's heating tape, Huener's appliance diagnostic and Heuer's pressure transmitter are each, on their faces, improvements in crowded fields — none claims, and none is here given, a "first" of its kind. Result, printed as the searched negative the assignment allows: the patent record worked for this ground carries no contested-first device or process, and no first claim for this ground was found in the record at patent strength. Any first asserted for this ground in future must name its patent or be printed, as here, as unpatented.

Sources:

  1. Indiana Business Magazine, 1990, via The Free Library — "world's most advanced cold-rolled steel finishing mill" as company officials' characterization, technology patterned after the Hirohata pilot plant, https://www.thefreelibrary.com/I%2FN+Tek+rolls.-a09223717
  2. Circopedia — Circus Ring of Fame list, the Risley act named after Richard Risley Carlisle, who developed this type of act, https://www.circopedia.org/index.php?title=Circus_Ring_of_Fame&oldid=38844

Cite this page

Using this page? Copy a credit line. Last updated November 12, 2026.

Source: Contested Firsts — No "First" Claim Survives as a Patent Claim for This Ground, Moosed History by Project Moosed, https://history.projectmoosed.com/usa/midwest/indiana/new-carlisle/inventors-inventions/contested-firsts-no-first-claim-survives-as-a-patent/