MoosedHistory
Menu
Crime & Public Safety

Crime & Public Safety

The enforcement succession: the sheriff's line, in the anchors the record keeps

The exact page text, read by your browser's voice.

1831–2027 · NAMED WHERE THE RECORD NAMES; THE GAPS NAMED TOO

The office that has policed this ground for two centuries is the sheriff's, and its line is printed here at the strength the record carries — anchored where documents anchor it, and openly gapped where they do not. The founding names stand in the first-law article: Samuel L. Cottrell, paid for sheriff's services in September 1831 and described by Chapman as holding the office "for several terms," and Benjamin McCarty, sheriff by the November term of 1831. Between McCarty and the modern era the line is not recoverable from the sources reached for this build, and it is carried as a named gap with its settling sources — the county's own officer rosters and John B. Stoll's 1923 county account among them — rather than filled from inference.

The modern line the record does anchor runs as follows. Elmer Sokol won the office in 1966 — the last Republican to hold it, his obituary records — after twenty-one years as a South Bend police captain; in his administration the department gained its first detective bureau and its first merit system, and the new county jail was built, opening in 1969 (a young Joe Speybroeck was hired in August 1969 among the deputies brought on to open it). Speybroeck himself was elected sheriff in 1994, served 1995–1998, and lost his bid for re-election in 1998. Frank Canarecci held the office through the 2000s and resigned in 2010, between the primary and the general election; a caucus of precinct committeemen chose an interim, and in November 2010 Michael Grzegorek was elected, serving the two terms that followed. Grzegorek's name returns in this section below, in a second office: commander of the county's homicide unit in its final year. Bill Redman — who had joined the department as a special deputy in 1994 — was elected sheriff in 2018 and re-elected in 2022, serving from January 1, 2019; term-limited in 2026, he left the office to win the county commissionership of District 1, this ground's own district, on November 3, 2026. The sheriff-elect is Scott Ruszkowski, South Bend's police chief since October 2015, who defeated county police officer Rod Laureys on November 3, 2026, with 47,951 votes in the county's count, and takes the office — and with it the patrol of this ground — on January 1, 2027.

The prosecuting side of the succession, at its documented points: Michael Dvorak stands as prosecutor in 2003, when the county's homicide unit was reorganized under his office; Ken Cotter holds the office through the documented span of the 2010s and 2020s — his office's statements run from the Patel-era prosecutions to the 2021 dissolution of the metro units and the 2026 public dispute over the unit's numbers — with Amy Cressy as his chief deputy in the charging documents of 2022. Cressy was elected prosecutor in her own right on November 3, 2026, and takes office January 1, 2027. The sheriff's line between 1831 and 1966, and again between Sokol's defeat for re-election in 1970 and Speybroeck's election in 1994, stands as this section's largest named gap; its settlers are named in the closing article.

Sources: Chapman (1880) and the 1875 atlas (the 1831 anchors). South Bend Tribune obituary of Elmer Sokol, as preserved in the INGenWeb St. Joseph County obituary collection (the 1966 election; the detective bureau, merit system and jail of his administration; the 1970 re-election loss). Miller v. St. Joseph County, No. 2:11-cv-217 (N.D. Ind. 2014) (Canarecci's 2010 resignation; the interim caucus; Grzegorek's election of November 4, 2010). Redress South Bend, August 11, 2026 (Speybroeck's service, 1995–1998; his August 1969 hiring for the new jail). South Bend Tribune, April 2026 and January 2026 (Redman's career: joined 1994; elected 2018 and 2022; term limits); the Tribune's election results of November 3, 2026, as carried in the Government leg (Ruszkowski, 47,951; Redman's election as commissioner; Cressy's election as prosecutor). The prosecutor anchors: the Tribune, September 2021 (the 2003 reorganization under Dvorak); the prosecutor's office statements of September 2, 2021 (Cotter) and the probable-cause affidavit of June 8, 2022 (Cressy, chief deputy).

Cite this page

Using this page? Copy a credit line. Last updated November 12, 2026.

Source: The enforcement succession: the sheriff's line, in the anchors the record keeps, Moosed History by Project Moosed, https://history.projectmoosed.com/usa/midwest/indiana/granger/crime-public-safety/enforcement-succession-the-sheriff-s-line-in-the-anchors/