The exact page text, read by your browser's voice.
City Controversies
Every city keeps a second record alongside its official one: the episodes its people argued about in courtrooms, council chambers, and the press, where the charge and the answer both survive in writing. This page collects South Bend's — the disputes that meet a strict test. Each had to be documented in court records, official findings, or the contemporaneous press of record; each had to be genuinely contested, with a charge and a defense on paper; and each had to change something — an office, a policy, a building, or the city's standing. Every entry carries its ending: a conviction, a settlement, a judgment, a resignation, or an honest statement that the matter is still open. Where the surviving record is one-sided, the entry says so.
The boundaries with the neighboring accounts are deliberate. The Natatorium campaign and the 1980 school-desegregation litigation belong to Black History & Civil Rights; the 1924 clash between the Ku Klux Klan and Notre Dame students belongs to Events; the Four Winds trust fight belongs to Before the City; the urban-renewal displacement count stands in Government; and offenses and prosecutions as crimes belong to Crime. What this page owns is the dispute itself, as a civic episode.
The Police Tapes: Fourteen Years Over Five Cassettes
2011–2026
The longest controversy in the city's modern record began with a telephone line. Line 6031 in the South Bend Police Department had been set to record in 2005, at the request of the officer then assigned to it, who had been…
1,000 Houses in 1,000 Days
2013–2019
On February 27, 2013 the city's Vacant and Abandoned Properties Task Force — co-chaired by James Kelly of the Notre Dame Law School — released its report, and Mayor Buttigieg set the goal that named the program: one thousand…
Smart Streets and the Signal at South and Michigan
2015–2017
Smart Streets was the Buttigieg administration's downtown wager: more than $20 million, much of it tax-increment financing, to convert the one-way streets that had funneled traffic through downtown since the 1970s — Main Street…
The Housing Authority Fraud
2015–2026
The largest public-corruption case in the city's modern record was not made in City Hall but in the Housing Authority of South Bend, the federally funded agency that owns and runs more than 800 public housing homes. Its executive…
The Community Resident Card and the Records Fight
2016–2020
In December 2016 La Casa de Amistad, the city's Latino advocacy organization, unveiled the Community Resident Card — the "SB ID" — an identification card for residents, including undocumented immigrants, who could not obtain…
The Shooting of Eric Logan and Its Three Verdicts
2019–2023
In the early hours of June 16, 2019, Sergeant Ryan O'Neill, a nineteen-year veteran of the South Bend Police Department, was investigating a string of car break-ins — seven reported that night — in the parking lot of the Central…
Clay High School and the One-Dollar Law
2023–2026 — still open
Clay High School, opened in 1939 on the city's north side, was the largest single piece of the South Bend Community School Corporation's Facilities Master Plan, adopted by the school board on April 17, 2023, by a vote of 4–3…